navigation
a webmaster learning community
     Home    Register     Search      Help      Login    
FrontPage Alternative
Sponsors

Shopping Cart Software
Ecommerce software integrated into Frontpage, Dreamweaver and Golive templates. No monthly fees and available in ASP and PHP versions.

Website Templates
We also have a wide selection of Dreamweaver, Expression Web and Frontpage templates as well as webmaster tools and CSS layouts.

Frontpage website templates
Creative Website Templates for FrontPage, Dreamweaver, Flash, SwishMax

Search Forums
 

Advanced search
Recent Posts

 Todays Posts
 Most Active posts
 Posts since last visit
 My Recent Posts
 Mark posts read

 

Is this where I want to go?

 
View related threads: (in this forum | in all forums)

Logged in as: Guest
Users viewing this topic: none
Printable Version 

All Forums >> Web Design >> Site Critiques >> Is this where I want to go?
Page: [1]
 
Ned the Red

 

Posts: 22
From: Dallas, TX USA
Status: offline

 
Is this where I want to go? - 10/22/2001 13:30:00   
Help me out. I've put together a site for an organization I'm in. I like it - although I know it needs a lot of work. I have been haunting these forums and have learned quite a lot from everyone and I thank you for all of the info. The problem is that some of the people in the group really like the pages of another group some of hem belong to. I really don't. Would you mind taking a look at it and helping me with some ammunition? I really don't want to go in this direction. The site is at:
http://www.ntxapics.org/
Or, maybe you'll tell me it's great. Then I'll just eat crow and start builing.
thanks
Gil

 

Posts: 7533
From: North Carolina, USA
Status: offline

 
RE: Is this where I want to go? - 10/22/2001 13:38:00   
I got a blank white page - looked at the source and see it's a frameset - but you forgot the >noframes> content...

------------------
Gil Harvey
The Host Factory
Resellers are our speciality
"Indecision may or may not be my problem"


(in reply to Ned the Red)
EWD

 

Posts: 1052
From: BeauFlow, NY
Status: offline

 
RE: Is this where I want to go? - 10/22/2001 15:01:00   
Welllll... It's better than some APICS sites I've seen but I'm not a fan of frames. The top frame takes up too much space, the text in the main frame is too bunched together and the colors are boring. But if I wanted excitement I wouldn't look for it at APICS! Good luck!

(in reply to Ned the Red)
Bill Nicol

 

Posts: 1445
From: Springfield IL USA
Status: offline

 
RE: Is this where I want to go? - 10/22/2001 16:12:00   
Ditto, ditto, ditto on the frames. Ackkkk.

Please ditch them. Might look good to you, but as a surfer, I usually keep right on going when I have to deal with frames....

If there's anything I've learned from Outfront, it's tables, tables, tables.

No problem with the colors, the subject matter really IS dry, at least to me, but meaningful to the right crowd.

Other than that, pretty nice site.

------------------
Bagpipes, there's only nine notes, how hard can it be?


(in reply to Ned the Red)
mittvet

 

Posts: 41
From: Mittagong NSW Australia
Status: offline

 
RE: Is this where I want to go? - 10/22/2001 16:34:00   
Ned
I'm very conservative but think the site you've shown is so much on the dry side and looks like it has come out of a cookie cutter. You said that "is that where you want to go"? I think you already have answered that yourself. I personally don't lie the site - it's (too me) very boring.
But having said that I too am a newbie and struggling to get it right with my own site ;-)


(in reply to Ned the Red)
Ned the Red

 

Posts: 22
From: Dallas, TX USA
Status: offline

 
RE: Is this where I want to go? - 10/22/2001 17:24:00   
OK, you've all pretty much confirmed my thinking. Now for the hard part - the site I'm working on is at:

http://www.napmdallas.org/index.html

Keep in mind that I don't have any graphics package to spiff it up with (that's in the works) and I've been pretty much flying by the seat of my pants as I've built this and received input from the other members - we didn't really have a plan for how we wanted it to look and function when we started. Also, it IS a site dedicated to a pretty boring bunch of folks (myself included).

I'm about ready to get a graphics package to use and when that's on my computer I plan to do some major re-designing. But.... what do you think? Better? Worse?


(in reply to Ned the Red)
abbeyvet

 

Posts: 5095
From: Kilkenny Ireland
Status: offline

 
RE: Is this where I want to go? - 10/22/2001 18:39:00   
It has no frames, that is an imporvment. It does badly need some graphics and the layout is a bit basic.

I would lose the navigation that you are using. It puzzled me for a while - I could see it in the code and couldn't figure out where it was on the page - and I use the internet a LOT!! Your navigation should be a no brainer. What you are using is more suited to news items or something than to a sites main navigation. You really need to have navigation in the same place on each page of your site - it makes users feel secure.

I see you are using FP 2000 - you should have Image Composer on the second disc. It is a pretty good graphics programme, certainly well up to creating good graphics for your site and it will cost you nothing, I use it an awful lot and get good results and it is easy to learn.

Another good way to learn is to buy a template - they only cost a few dollars and even if you do not use the one you buy, playing with it will teach you a lot about setting out pages effectively.

------------------
Katherine

InKK Design
LinKKs - Kilkenny's Online Magazine


-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*
"Dogs have owners, cats have staff!"

[This message has been edited by abbeyvet (edited 10-22-2001).]


(in reply to Ned the Red)
EWD

 

Posts: 1052
From: BeauFlow, NY
Status: offline

 
RE: Is this where I want to go? - 10/22/2001 19:42:00   
Katherine's comments are right on, as usual. I was confused by the navigation also, and that's not good, when web designers don't understand it! It needs to be intuitive and consistent- in the same place on every page. There are some wonderful templates available here, and I think the template called "Now" would be perfect for an APICS or NAPM site. The only other comment I have initially is the font size on the links page is really huge... had to scroll and scroll to see it all. Might be better to have two table cells side by side with links to bring more of them into view. Best of luck with it!

(in reply to Ned the Red)
Ned the Red

 

Posts: 22
From: Dallas, TX USA
Status: offline

 
RE: Is this where I want to go? - 10/22/2001 22:21:00   
Thanks for the comments. As I said, I built this and designed it as I went... now it's time to rebuild using all I've learned from y'all.

thanks again,


(in reply to Ned the Red)
mittvet

 

Posts: 41
From: Mittagong NSW Australia
Status: offline

 
RE: Is this where I want to go? - 10/23/2001 20:53:00   
Ned
I too am a newbie (that's obvious to any who visit my webpage..), I played with a few templates that i purchased - some through pixelmill and one through My Arts Desire. I was just learning FP2000 and was getting pretty cheesed off with it and then tried my hand at NetObjects Fusion MX, but now have returned to FP 2002. The main reason I returned to fiddle with FP was that I had a guy put together a template from tendering out on www.elance.com. He was very reasonable price wise and gave me the navigation elements that I liked and played with some graphics I sent him. He sent me back the template which I could work with better in FP2002 than NetObjects, so I have kept with FP and also played with a bit of Swish. (I can send you his details if you like)

Good luck.

keith


(in reply to Ned the Red)
Bill Nicol

 

Posts: 1445
From: Springfield IL USA
Status: offline

 
RE: Is this where I want to go? - 10/23/2001 20:34:00   
Hi Ned,

I'm in total agreement with Katherine on this one, especially the template solution. Shop where you wish, but you will find a pretty excellent selection right here at Outfront at extremely reasonable prices(and I'm not getting any $$$ for this endorsement so you can believe it). I've used a couple and believe me, you can't beat the ease with which you get a beautiful site going... but here's the really GREAT part... you get fantastic support and in many cases get to talk with the authors of the templates when you need help with installation or modification.

As for Swish or Flash...don't get tempted by it. It's flamboyant and flashy, but it takes forever to load, and ticks off many surfers (myself included) when they have to sit there and wait for it to load. Maybe a couple of years down the road when all the line speeds and CPU's run faster, it might not be a big deal, but for now, it's pretty much just a resource hog.

Have a great one.... good luck

------------------
Bagpipes, there's only nine notes, how hard can it be?


(in reply to Ned the Red)
mittvet

 

Posts: 41
From: Mittagong NSW Australia
Status: offline

 
RE: Is this where I want to go? - 10/23/2001 20:05:00   
Just to clarify - I think Bill was having a go at me...
I think outfronts templates are good looking - they just didn't meet my requirements... I was very tempted but found they didn't reflect me or my occupation - sorry guys.

I have tried swish and indeed many outfront templates include some swish .. take a look and see what you think at www.mittagongvet.com.au


I agree that many flash sites are time consuming to load - just take a look at www.petalia.com and do a search for some vets. there and see how tedious it is to get to the point.

Cheers

Keith McKellar Stewart


(in reply to Ned the Red)
Bill Nicol

 

Posts: 1445
From: Springfield IL USA
Status: offline

 
RE: Is this where I want to go? - 10/23/2001 20:15:00   
Hi Keith,

Seriously, I wasn't having a go at you... Merely expressing an opinion. You are correct that there are other templates available and some with Swish, and some that might suit an individual better.

It's easy for newbies (and I don't really exclude myself in this category) to become enthralled by technology such as Swish.

I'm just a bit partial to the folks here at Outfront and the support, cheerfulness, and friendliness that I witness here every single day.

Sorry if my post sounded any other way, it certainly wasn't intentional.

Cheers

------------------
Bagpipes, there's only nine notes, how hard can it be?


(in reply to Ned the Red)
LB

 

Posts: 5551
From: Montana USA
Status: offline

 
RE: Is this where I want to go? - 10/23/2001 20:35:00   
I'm feeling like the black sheep on this thread, but I don't see anything wrong with what Ned is doing so far.

Content is/was/will always be King. I'd much rather visit a site lacking in graphics and pizzazz than one that's lacking in good content. Fast to load and easy to get to can make a site a joy to view.

Nothing wrong with using frames in my own opinion, but you have a lot more bases to cover (noframes content, search engines, usability, etc) and often you can do the same job without them with much less effort.

I agree about the menu. It didn't take me long to catch on this time, but the first time I came to a site with this kind of menu I was absolutely lost for too long. You're going to lose some people there. If you keep it, be sure to also have some "normal" text links as an alternate navigation. Instead of the "site map", it's nice to have a consistent full navigation on every page.

I'd get rid of some of that extra white space at the bottom of the home page. (details, details )

If you want to give it a more professional feel without much work, then templates are nice. If you like what you are doing and having fun at it... keep after it, you're doing fine!

Linda

ps - be sure to check in Netscape... in version 4.7 some of the text is off a bit from how it shows in IE.

------------------
Frontpage Web Templates

[This message has been edited by LB (edited 10-23-2001).]


(in reply to Ned the Red)
mittvet

 

Posts: 41
From: Mittagong NSW Australia
Status: offline

 
RE: Is this where I want to go? - 10/23/2001 20:41:00   
Ned
:0 Sorry to waste your time - overzealous aussies can cause international incidents -
Bill and Katherine's advice seems very reasonable. But don't forget to look around at others - http://www.myartsdesire.com/ has some nice looking themes as well but then again they may be deemed the opposition from outfront point of view. It's late for an aussie - so must get some shuteye. Goodnight.

(in reply to Ned the Red)
LB

 

Posts: 5551
From: Montana USA
Status: offline

 
RE: Is this where I want to go? - 10/23/2001 23:07:00   
Discussions like these are never a waste of time. No need for apologies!

Links to other sites are always appreciated. We have often mentioned Karey's sites in the past... last time I went to post one of them, I came up with a dead link though. Either I had the url wrong, or she had stopped using it. Another site that has some nice templates is www.icemocha.com . First and foremost, the Outfront forums have ALWAYS been about helping each other.... if you are looking for templates, you aren't limited just to the ones here. (though don't miss checking ours out too )

Linda

------------------
Frontpage Web Templates


(in reply to Ned the Red)
LB

 

Posts: 5551
From: Montana USA
Status: offline

 
RE: Is this where I want to go? - 10/23/2001 23:10:00   
oops! since this has turned to discussing templates for sale, I'd better mention www.aplustemplates.com also.

(in reply to Ned the Red)
Page:   [1]

All Forums >> Web Design >> Site Critiques >> Is this where I want to go?
Page: [1]
Jump to: 1





New Messages No New Messages
Hot Topic w/ New Messages Hot Topic w/o New Messages
Locked w/ New Messages Locked w/o New Messages
 Post New Thread
 Reply to Message
 Post New Poll
 Submit Vote
 Delete My Own Post
 Delete My Own Thread
 Rate Posts