Request for critique and a question (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Web Design] >> Site Critiques



Message

vbmark -> Request for critique and a question (2/2/2006 14:57:58)

Hello,

Here are the two sites that I just finished setting up the framework for:

Christian Music Wiki
Obscure Music Wiki

Here are my questions for the experts:

1) How is the look/feel/navigation?

2) What do you think of the concept?

3) How do I go about finding people who would like to be a part of this sort of thing?

Thank you for your insight and taking the time to answer.

Sincerely,
Mark



Rocket Boy -> RE: Request for critique and a question (2/3/2006 13:59:38)

Now then vbmark... is it just spam or is it a serious request for a review on a perfectly standard message forum?

[:D]



vbmark -> RE: Request for critique and a question (2/3/2006 14:03:33)

It was serious. And in fact due to good feedback from other places I've decided to drop both of those sites. Mostly because of the comments I got on my questions number 2 and 3.

So, I'm going to try another project.

Thanks!
vbMark




Rocket Boy -> RE: Request for critique and a question (2/3/2006 15:22:49)

In that case I apologise.

You have not had a bad idea but you might struggle with the fact that most coding forums have a reviews section already (just a thought).

A possible idea on a way to get people onto your forum is to say that people who wish to advertise their site on the forum they must carry a link on their site which says "review my site" or "vote for me". Of course this could have a negative effect with some site owners.

[;)]



vbmark -> RE: Request for critique and a question (2/3/2006 15:47:38)

Wow, that is a really great idea. I have to think about that for awhile. Thank you for sharing that with me.



Rocket Boy -> RE: Request for critique and a question (2/3/2006 15:51:05)

Probably worth getting a good member base before you start issuing Terms & Conditions



billoutfrontforum -> RE: Request for critique and a question (2/9/2006 13:57:43)

You closed it up already?

Sometimes you've got to go with your gut.

I tried viewing but you'd already locked it out with a password requirement.

Good luck.



vbmark -> RE: Request for critique and a question (2/9/2006 14:00:18)

quote:

ORIGINAL: billoutfrontforum

You closed it up already?

Sometimes you've got to go with your gut.

I tried viewing but you'd already locked it out with a password requirement.

Good luck.


Yes, here is what I said above...

quote:

...due to good feedback from other places I've decided to drop both of those sites. Mostly because of the comments I got on my questions number 2 and 3.

So, I'm going to try another project.



Page: [1]

Valid CSS!




Forum Software © ASPPlayground.NET Advanced Edition 2.4.5 ANSI
0.109375