navigation
a webmaster learning community
     Home    Register     Search      Help      Login    
Sponsors

Shopping Cart Software
Ecommerce software integrated into Frontpage, Dreamweaver and Golive templates. No monthly fees and available in ASP and PHP versions.

Website Templates
We also have a wide selection of Dreamweaver, Expression Web and Frontpage templates as well as webmaster tools and CSS layouts.

Frontpage website templates
Creative Website Templates for FrontPage, Dreamweaver, Flash, SwishMax

Search Forums
 

Advanced search
Recent Posts

 Todays Posts
 Most Active posts
 Posts since last visit
 My Recent Posts
 Mark posts read

 

Ready for constructive criticism and suggestions

 
View related threads: (in this forum | in all forums)

Logged in as: Guest
Users viewing this topic: none
Printable Version 

All Forums >> Web Design >> Site Critiques >> Ready for constructive criticism and suggestions
Page: [1]
 
Teresa

 

Posts: 15
From: SF Bay Area, CA
Status: offline

 
Ready for constructive criticism and suggestions - 11/2/2001 14:24:00   
I am ready for some suggestions for improvements on my site - www.CavySpirit.com

I am planning on adding a subscription only component for access to some videos and other materials.

Also, I have another site which I need to overhaul and re-do. It will be more involved with a database component. I am tempted to use the same theme (with some tweaking) as the one I'm referencing here because I like it so much, but I don't want to. That's how I found this site--looking for a similar template--professional, clean, etc (at least in my opinion ).

I know the javascript is not compatible with older browsers, and I'd like to be able to test for that and deal with it. Don't know if that's possible.

Any suggestions, comments, etc are greatly appreciated.

Thanks,
Teresa

------------------
www.CavySpirit.com

abbeyvet

 

Posts: 5095
From: Kilkenny Ireland
Status: offline

 
RE: Ready for constructive criticism and suggestions - 11/2/2001 15:08:00   
It looks very well. I like the colours and the layout.

The only thing I would say is it takes forever to load - when the source is too big to open in Notepad, you have a problem! I would try to slim it down a little, well, a lot actually. It may mean losing the applet and some of the other stuff, hard decisions I know but unless you are sure all your users are on fast connections size matters a lot. I certainly would not have waited for it under normal circumstances.

------------------
Katherine

InKK Design
LinKKs - Kilkenny's Online Magazine


-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*
"Dogs have owners, cats have staff!"


(in reply to Teresa)
Non-Profit

 

Posts: 388
From: Virginia, USA
Status: offline

 
RE: Ready for constructive criticism and suggestions - 11/2/2001 15:22:00   
Teresa,

I visited using IE 5.0 and I waited over 2 minutes for the homepage to load and it didn't finish. After pressing Stop on my browser your homepage came up but I don't know if what I saw was all of it or not. Maybe the slowness was a result of that adoptables show on your homepage but I'm definitely not the one to talk to about that!

One thing I think that your site might benefit from are some bookmarks especially in the longer pages (e.g, news). As it is, that's a long scroll and I knkow that that turns some people off from a site.

I just a beginner with FP, so take all my comments with a grain of salt.

Tony


(in reply to Teresa)
Teresa

 

Posts: 15
From: SF Bay Area, CA
Status: offline

 
RE: Ready for constructive criticism and suggestions - 11/2/2001 15:27:00   
Thanks!

Okay, up until my last update, I've been praised for a fast loading site! I added one additional photo to the javascript applet for a total of 5. I think that must be one too many. I just went back down to 4, and took out a few of the other javascript control buttons.

Now, it loads right away again for me. Please check it out again and tell my what you think...

Thanks much,
Teresa

------------------
www.CavySpirit.com


(in reply to Teresa)
abbeyvet

 

Posts: 5095
From: Kilkenny Ireland
Status: offline

 
RE: Ready for constructive criticism and suggestions - 11/2/2001 15:55:00   
It still took over 2 minutes to fully load for me. You reduced it's size form something over 69000 bytes to 64560 bytes. This is still a HUGE page - you need to be aiming for something less than half that size at least.

------------------
Katherine

InKK Design
LinKKs - Kilkenny's Online Magazine


-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*
"Dogs have owners, cats have staff!"


(in reply to Teresa)
Teresa

 

Posts: 15
From: SF Bay Area, CA
Status: offline

 
RE: Ready for constructive criticism and suggestions - 11/2/2001 17:17:00   
I am using a cable modem, so I went to one of my older, dial up machines. I went in through an AOL connection at less than a 50K connection speed and it fully loaded for me in 20-25 seconds.

How are you finding the size of the page? I'm not sure how to do that. And is just the size of the html that impacts performance? Since the javascript preloads 4 photos, at about 18-19K each, doesn't that also impact load time beyond the html size?


I'll definitely add a mini-toc at the top of my news page. It is getting too long.

Thanks,
Teresa


(in reply to Teresa)
abbeyvet

 

Posts: 5095
From: Kilkenny Ireland
Status: offline

 
RE: Ready for constructive criticism and suggestions - 11/2/2001 18:24:00   
20 - 25 seconds is very considerably faster than it loaded for me but it is still very slow.

To get the size of the page, righ click anywhere in an empty area of the page and choose properties. It might be useful to compare your site with some others, to give an idea of what works well.

------------------
Katherine

InKK Design
LinKKs - Kilkenny's Online Magazine


-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*
"Dogs have owners, cats have staff!"

[This message has been edited by abbeyvet (edited 11-02-2001).]


(in reply to Teresa)
joy

 

Posts: 176
From: Gilbert AZ USA
Status: offline

 
RE: Ready for constructive criticism and suggestions - 11/2/2001 18:31:00   
Awe! Cute little fluffy guys. It took 53 seconds to load for me using my dsl connection. Other than that, I think it is a very nice site. You might be able to reduce the load time by making regular gif rollover buttons for your navigation insead of using a script for that, or maybe moving the polls to a separate page.

From a fellow "anti-pet stores" crusader, keep up the good work! -Joy

------------------
MyDog8it Design
SunState Consulting


(in reply to Teresa)
Teresa

 

Posts: 15
From: SF Bay Area, CA
Status: offline

 
RE: Ready for constructive criticism and suggestions - 11/2/2001 20:19:00   
Okay, I moved the polls to a separate page. I still am not able to get the file size. Every place I try it tells me the size is "Not available."

If I change the navigation bar, I need to change it in the theme. Is is possible to do programatically? Or do I have to hard code it? Not sure. ???

Any load time improvement without the polls?

Thanks,
Teresa


(in reply to Teresa)
Teresa

 

Posts: 15
From: SF Bay Area, CA
Status: offline

 
RE: Ready for constructive criticism and suggestions - 11/3/2001 20:11:00   
Okay, in addition to moving polls, significantly shortened the front page. Removed two main pages on from the nav bar to links from other pages. Updated the news page with a mini toc.

Hope the load time is better and the content looks just as interesting. I rather liked having the polls on the front page, but can live without it.

------------------
www.CavySpirit.com


(in reply to Teresa)
LB

 

Posts: 5551
From: Montana USA
Status: offline

 
RE: Ready for constructive criticism and suggestions - 11/3/2001 23:25:00   
Hi, Teresa -

You have an awesome site, but the home page in particular is not optimised for slower connections. The quickest, biggest change you could make is to put a single photo on the home page. The Frontlook Applet looks great, but the 4 photos combined are 69927 bytes and by putting them into a java applet (slower loading than javascripts) it increases the loading time even more. If you go for a single image here, you *might* be able to add those polls back in without too much of an increase in time.

The other thing that is making the load time seem so long is that all the content is nested inside one large table. I'm not sure why it was designed that way, but when you have some time I'd suggest on working on one blank page and re-do the layout without so much nesting. There are one or two tables you don't need that are holding the rest of the tables inside them. You might also email the designer of this layout and ask if they'd be willing to do one page like that for you.

I know you have a ton of content that would need to be copied into a new layout if you did this, but for the long-term usability of the site I think you should consider working on it. Although many people are getting high-speed connections, there is still a huge section of viewers using 24k or slower. The browser won't start to show anything until it's read the content of the first table, which includes the whole page. With stacked tables, it'll quickly show the first one while the next table loads.

The small photos of you and Robert are a bit fuzzy. I'd skip the links to the larger ones and improve the ones that are immediately shown.

Since most of your navigation is done with graphics, I would consider a text link to the site map a must. The top level navigation could be a graphic for the squares and text links... you could keep them white and not underlined by using an inline CSS.

Very huge, informational, wonderful site.

The only other suggestion (not looking in Netscape here, so hopefully that is fine) is to reset your monitor resolution to 800x600 to test view your sites (cavyspirit and cavycages). Some of the pages have a horizontal scroll, others don't. That should be an easy fix.

Linda


------------------
Frontpage Web Templates

[This message has been edited by LB (edited 11-03-2001).]


(in reply to Teresa)
Teresa

 

Posts: 15
From: SF Bay Area, CA
Status: offline

 
RE: Ready for constructive criticism and suggestions - 11/3/2001 23:45:00   
Is there any way to test for the connection speed before presenting the page? I love that applet that gives me a slide show of the photos. I seem to recall seeing some scripts somewhere that can do that.

I'm never sure what little change I'm making that somehow throws off the width of the page causing a horizontal scroll. And with all the darn tables, I find it tricky to figure out how to correct it!

I will contact the author and see what might be possible. I really like the overall theme. I need to completely redo my cavy rescue site and was thinking about using the same theme but changing a color.



(in reply to Teresa)
Teresa

 

Posts: 15
From: SF Bay Area, CA
Status: offline

 
RE: Ready for constructive criticism and suggestions - 11/5/2001 20:49:00   
The theme guys told me to deactivate 'active graphics' in the theme. I did that on the home page.

Does that help the loading time? If it's signficant, then I'll try the gif rollovers somehow instead.

Thanks


(in reply to Teresa)
Goober

 

Posts: 1156
From: Pennsylvania USA
Status: offline

 
RE: Ready for constructive criticism and suggestions - 11/5/2001 20:58:00   
I am getting a side to side scroll on every page in Netscape. Also, there are zero margin settings for IE but not NN. You need to add marginwidth="0" marginheight="0" to the body tag.

Sandy

------------------
Stu Reilly Design
TheTemplateStore
Allegheny Web
Dreamweaver Sites


(in reply to Teresa)
Teresa

 

Posts: 15
From: SF Bay Area, CA
Status: offline

 
RE: Ready for constructive criticism and suggestions - 11/5/2001 15:06:00   
Okay, I cleaned up the margins so it shows better in NN. Also, realized I had some yukky NN formatting on my right-hand side-bars (extraneous parapraphs for centering). Fixed those, too.

But, now I notice that the formatting regarding spacing is different on NN as compared to how I really want the spacing on IE. I'm using NN 6.1 at the moment. How the heck do I reconcile the right way to space using br's and p's? The main page (index) is the way the header part should look, in both NN and IE, I'll have to clean up all the other pages so that they display properly in NN. But, the body (or bulk) of the content on the main page shows the way I want it in IE, but has too much space in NN. Yuk. What to do?

Can someone point me in the right direction?

Thanks,
Teresa (www.cavyspirit.com)


(in reply to Teresa)
Page:   [1]

All Forums >> Web Design >> Site Critiques >> Ready for constructive criticism and suggestions
Page: [1]
Jump to: 1





New Messages No New Messages
Hot Topic w/ New Messages Hot Topic w/o New Messages
Locked w/ New Messages Locked w/o New Messages
 Post New Thread
 Reply to Message
 Post New Poll
 Submit Vote
 Delete My Own Post
 Delete My Own Thread
 Rate Posts